Back to the West Nile Virus listserv archive.

Date: 7 Aug 2003
Posted by: Dominick Ninivaggi <Dominick.Ninivaggi@co.suffolk.ny.us>

From: Dominick Ninivaggi  <Dominick.Ninivaggi@co.suffolk.ny.us>

Here is a different take on some recent concerns about mosquito 
control pesticides:

Competitive Enterprise Institute

Activists More to Fear than Pesticides
Logomasini Op-Ed for Scripps Howard
by Angela Logomasini
August 5, 2003

As public health officials consider spraying pesticides to control 
the mosquito-borne West Nile virus, anti-pesticide activists claim 
that spraying devastates birds and other wildlife. But such claims 
should be viewed with skepticism.

It seems that West Nile virus and other natural factors may pose much 
greater threats than spraying. The Centers for Disease Control 
reports that West Nile has killed birds from at least 138 bird 
species, including some endangered species.

In the Midwest last year, 400 great-horned owls were found dead from 
West Nile. Researchers estimate that for each dead bird reported, 
there are probably 100 to 1,000 unreported cases, which means there 
could have been as many as 40,000 to 400,000 great-horned owl deaths 
from West Nile last year.

Still, environmentalists claim that there is clear evidence that the 
pesticides are a far greater risk to birds. They claimed back in 2001 
that data from New York State showed that more birds were dying from 
"toxins" like pesticides than from West Nile.

But science writer Steven Milloy obtained state data in 2001 that 
showed the toxins that affected the birds in this sample were mostly 
naturally occurring. According to Milloy, the New York State analysis 
of 3,216 dead birds found that natural diseases and toxins caused the 
majority of the bird deaths (1,263 from West Nile virus and 1,100 
from botulinum).

Meanwhile, the data included 219 pesticide-related bird deaths, of 
which 30 were from intentional poisonings of pest birds and 100 were 
from illegal use of pesticides for intentional killing of birds. 
Twenty-seven bird deaths resulted from lawn care products.

More recently, the Audubon Society says that data collected by New 
York State in subsequent years from a sample of 80,000 dead birds 
shows that pesticides, primarily lawn products, are killing the 
majority of birds. Yet New York has not released the data in any 
report, nor has anything been peer-reviewed. This "majority" of such 
toxin-related deaths may again include natural toxins, like 
botulinum, and it is not clear that the data they obtained was for 
all 80,000 birds.

Unfortunately, the data on bird deaths from all sources isn't 
particularly clear, despite Audubon's suggestions to the contrary. 
The researcher who conducts New York bird pathology (who reportedly 
gave the data to the Audubon Society) has told the press that he 
doubts spraying will do much harm to birds--at least not as much as 
does the virus. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency asserts that 
spraying poses a negligible risk to birds. In addition to birds, 
activists also say that aquatic life is at grave risk.

When a massive lobster die-off occurred in Long Island Sound in 1999, 
environmentalists and lobstermen claimed that New York City's 
malathion spraying had reached the waters and caused the die-off. Yet 
the die-off began before New York State sprayed, and several years of 
federally- funded research hasn't found a definitive link to the 
pesticides.

The University of Connecticut's Dr. Richard French explained in a 
2001 report: "There is no quantitative evidence of pesticide toxicity 
... All the indications based on pathological evaluation of the 
American Lobster in LIS (Long Island Sound), suggest that the mass 
mortality of lobsters in 1999 was the effect of a natural disease."

Long Island comprises some of the farthest southern reaches for these 
lobsters, and unusually warm waters in years leading up to and into 
1999 seem to have created natural environmental stresses that make 
the shellfish more susceptible to parasites and other diseases.

In any case, New York's regional problem has not stopped the industry 
from growing. According to figures from the National Marine Fisheries 
Service, the biggest national lobster catch occurred in 1999--the 
year New York suffered its massive die-off. The data show that since 
1950, the lobster catch has increased through the decades, with some 
years dipping only to be followed by the continued march upward. New 
York's lobster population is more variable.

Before the 1990s, average annual lobster catch for all the years 
between 1950 and 1989 totaled less than a million pounds a year. The 
number of lobsters caught ballooned in the 1990s, amounting to more 
than three million pounds by 1992 and then reaching a pinnacle of 
nearly nine and a half million pounds in 1996. The yields for 1999 
(seven million pounds) and 2000 (three million) are still higher than 
any year before 1990. Debates about pesticide spraying aren't going 
away, and anti-pesticide activists will continue to make unsupported 
claims to advance their cause.

But much of what they say isn't verified by the facts.
http://www.cei.org/gencon/019,03591.cfm

----------------------------------------------------------------------------
WESTNILEVIRUS-L is an email discussion group for communication and
discussion about West Nile Virus, particularly regarding policy, risk
reduction and public education issues. It is moderated by Dr. Lois Levitan,
Program Leader of the Cornell Environmental Risk Analysis Program.
Subscribers are encouraged to post to the group by sending an email to:
WESTNILEVIRUS-L@cornell.edu.  Postings must be written in plain,
unformatted text, and sent without attachments.  The subject line must
begin with the identifier [WNV-L], followed by a meaningful subject
description.  Archives are posted at:
http://environmentalrisk.cornell.edu/WNV/WNV-LArchiveIndex.cfm.
To subscribe (or unsubscribe), send an email request to
envrisk@cornell.edu. To receive messages once a day in digest
format, subscribers should send an email to listproc@cornell.edu
with message: "set WESTNILEVIRUS-L mail digest-nomime".
----------------------------------------------------------------------------